So, I met with Jay Botwinick last night, and both wanted to thank Mongo for the recommendation, and give a strong recommendation of my own.
Jay looked at my return from last year, pointed out several things that my prior accountant had done wrong that could potentially get me in trouble, looked at the documents I brought, and basically told me that paying him to do my taxes would be a waste of money, and that I could handle it myself pretty easily. I didn't have to pay him a thing. Then he offered to review my return after I prepare it for a box of donuts.
Jay was honest to his own detriment and reassuring. If I was in a situation where I needed an accountant (which apparently I'm not anymore), I'd definitely use him in the future.